So the remake of Tactics Ogre is out now, and I highly suggest everyone play it at least once. But the question is, which is better? Tactics Ogre, or Final Fantasy Tactics? To make all things fair I'll be comparing the two PSP remakes.
WARNING: THERE WILL BE SPOILERS.
Gameplay:
This one is more fair then you might at first think. The original Tactics Ogre came out two years before Final Fantasy Tactics and it showed, but since they've both been remade they're on a much more even keel. The main issue at hand in the remakes is lag: FFT is full of it. The PSP remake of Final Fantasy Tactics struggles especially hard to render magic effects and lags a lot.
We've moved past this, right? This isn't a PC game where every system is different. Excepting firmware updates all PSPs run basically the same. You know what the system is capable of, WORK WITH IT. There's no excuse for lag in a non-PC game, sorry.
WINNER: TACTICS OGRE
Story:
It's very important there be no misunderstanding here. Tactics Ogre's story is dark, and so is Final Fantasy Tactics' story. But there's a difference. In TO, the island of Valeria starts out crapsack. Racism and greed rule the country, your own people are beaten and broken and being herded onto reservations and as the game proceeds a lot of good people die who shouldn't have had to, but in the end things are better. You unite the country, and not by wiping out the other races but by overcoming racism, unifying against a common foe. Instead of being Galgastani or Walister or Bakram you become simply Valerians. You forge true peace.
On the other hand, we have Ivalice. Ivalice starts out crapsack, being ruled by the fascist elite who treat everyone else as little more than slaves. After literally every remotely good person dies the elitist aristocracy wins, erases your name and deeds from history, and continues their stranglehold for the next few thousand years...but hey, at least the world wasn't destroyed. That's not the bad ending, either. That's the ONLY ending.
To put it simply, there's a difference between dark and gritty, and just pointless. FFT is pointless.
That said, Delita owns your ass.
WINNER: TACTICS OGRE (even despite Delita)
Customization:
If there's one place Final Fantasy Tactics wins it's here. The customization is pretty much the one saving grace of FFT. It's why people can beat the game, scream bullshit on the ending, then keep playing anyway.
Tactics Ogre's remake added a skills system that gave the previously dull classes their own unique flavor and life. Unlike Final Fantasy, however, Tactics Ogre's fun skills are almost all class-exclusive. Got dreams of an Angel Knight that uses fire magic and two-handed swords? Well TOO BAD because both of those skills are exclusive to other classes! The few hybrid classes there are tend to just suck.
There is a little bit of customization in Tactics Ogre, but it's way too restrictive...oddly enough, the original was much less restrictive, even if only because the classes were so poorly defined.
WINNER: FINAL FANTASY TACTICS
Content:
Tactics Ogre is a MUCH bigger game, for the most part. There are more side-areas and way more to do. Compare the big side-dungeon from both games. Tactic's Ogre's Palace of the Dead is 115 floors, compared to FFT's big dungeon's 50 floors. There's more game, more classes. Non-human races also don't entirely suck in Tactics Ogre, mostly due to being able to (as of the remake) use more than one class. So that's another dimension of gameplay added right there.
On the other hand, equipment options are extremely limited in the remake. In FFT and the original TO, you had tons of different weapons, some of which had element as their only real difference, so you could mix and match to fit what you needed. In the remake there's very sparse options and pretty much everything is organized by tiers, worst equipment to best.
Equipment options are further limited by class, either outright (ie. rune fencers can't use axes) or by making anything else pointless (ie. two-handed swords are the only weapons with worthwhile abilities for a terror knight).
If we were talking about the original then Final Fantasy wouldn't stand a chance, but the remake severely reduced the content. The addition of worthwhile non-human units is a plus, but is outweighed by the fact that the equipment options are so anemic. As for the 115 floor Palace of the Dead...most of the floors are basically the same only re-arranged a little, flipped around, or starting you in a different spot.
WINNER: FINAL FANTASY TACTICS (barely)
OVERALL WINNER: TACTICS OGRE
Both games shine in different ways. Final Fantasy Tactics has an utterly terrible story, but much deeper character customization. Tactics Ogre has an extremely restrictive class system but a much better story. I'd suggest going with FFT for customization, but Tactics Ogre for everything else.
That said, the original Tactics Ogre beats the pants off both of them. I'd suggest trying to find it if I believed that was even remotely possible.
