Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Top X Epic Fails on Alone

Josh Chavez
Larry Roberts Fighting Nature
Jose's Boat

X. Josh Chavez (Season 1)


X. Joe Robinet loses his fire starter. (Season 1)
Fire is the gift of Prometheus that elevated mankind above the animals. It is the most important tool for any survivalist, period. Fire cooks your food, purifies your water, keeps you warm, and drives away predators. Being able to create and maintain a fire is even more important in an environment like the temperate rainforest of Vancouver Island. You can't just rub sticks together when the sticks are this wet. You need a fire starter, and Joe's fire starter was his ferro rod - an Iron/Cerium alloy rod that throws off 3,000°C sparks when struck. Sooooo, guess what Joe just happened to lose!

The worst part is, Joe was actually doing pretty well for himself. He'd started off in a bad spot, being dropped off in a swamp, but after hiking across his starting island and fording a river, he found a great spot with a freshwater stream and a beach to fish from. Obviously, the universe couldn't let that stand, and so dumped a heaping helping of Murphy's Law on him.

As near as can be told, Joe left the rod on his coat and then flung it off by mistake when picking the coat up, and the tide dragged it out to sea. Ultimately, Joe became an object lesson: even if you do everything right, all it takes is one mistake to lose it all.

(Randy Champagne in season 2 also lost his, dropping it into his fire.

X. Jim Shields fails at P.M.A. (Season 3)
Jim Shields was a high school teacher when he decided to take the challenge. He is also quite possibly the biggest disappointment to me personally. His entire thing was P.M.A. - Positive Mental Attitude. He taught this to all his students, to his family, to everyone that he knows.

Of course, all the positive thinking in the world won't help if you don't have the skills to back it up... but it wasn't even a lack of skill that cost Jim the win. He was the first to tap out in season 3, after only 2 days in the bush... because it was raining.

I'm going to say that again. Jim tapped out because it was raining, and I'm not talking about some monsoon that drenched his firewood and flooded his campsite. No, it had just been lightly raining for a day and it made Jim feel SO DEPRESSED that he immediately grabbed his radio and tapped out like an asshole. I also want to make it clear, that isn't my interpretation of what happened, that is the actual reason he gave for why he did it.

One thing you quickly find watching this show is the difference between real survivors and frauds. Jim Shields talked a big game, but clearly did not actually understand the lessons that he tries to teach others. He was nothing but a phony, probably just parroting things he heard from other, wiser people. Ultimately he put his loss down to "the one skill that you can't control - your brain." Pro tip, Jim: P.M.A. is 100% about controlling your stupid freaking brain.

X. Brant McGee drinks bad water. (Season 1)
Brant McGee from season 1 had some skills, but he ended up going home thanks to a one-two punch of stupid to rival Bear Grylls himself.

First, he was collecting brackish water to drink. He found an ocean inlet that drained down to little tidal pools during low tide, and had the brilliant idea that if he collected water from it just before the tide came back in, the salt would have filtered out and it would be safe. (It wasn't.)

Second, he didn't bother boiling his drinking water to sterilize it, instead filtering it through sphagnum moss. While it is well known that sphagnum (aka peat moss) can filter water, and is even used for filtering water in septic systems, the question of whether it can filter contaminants to a level fit for human consumption is... questionable at best. Either way, it definitely can NOT filter out salt.

After nearly a week of this, Brant was suffering hallucinations in the night, had shakes at all hours, and was clearly losing his grip on reality. At least he had enough sense left to realize he was losing it, and he tapped out after 6 days.

X. Desmond White sees bear poop. (Season 2)
You can always tell who's going to tap out the earliest based on who spends the most time trash-talking about how easy it's all going to be. You knew Desmond was going to be a real winner when some of the first words out of his mouth were "If a bear grab me, if someone see the bear fight, they need to help the bear!" Sure enough, the second he saw his first bit of bear sign in the woods, his entire attitude changed.

Another thing that's interesting about this show is watching the different ways that people respond to the same thing. While Josh Chavez had a panicked, screaming freakout, Desmond was much quieter. To his credit he really did try to keep working and push through his fear, but it was obvious that his spirit had been crushed. His morale didn't just crumble, it imploded into an all-consuming black hole of despair.

On day 1, after about 5 hours in the bush, Desmond White set the record for the fastest tap-out on the show, that still has yet to be beaten after 5 seasons.

No comments: